Have you heard of exercise balls used as desk seats? Would you consider using exercise balls instead of traditional chairs in your classroom?
That’s exactly what Rahni Kay Haverland, third grade teacher at St. Anthony School in Dubuque, Iowa did. Intrigued by the idea, we interviewed Rahni Kay to get a teacher’s perspective. Here is her insightful look the potential and pitfalls of this unusual seating arrangement.
What made you want to get the new seats?
My students’ needs were the main reason for wanting the balls. 3rd grade is a year where they are suddenly expected to sit still for longer periods of time. I do mini lessons and small group lessons, but I still had students who could not keep their chair legs on the floor or constantly rocked or tapped during short 5-10 minute lessons.
What do you call them?
We simply call them balls or exercise balls.
Had you ever tried them before you got them for your classroom?
We did have 2 balls in the classroom prior to receiving our classroom set. The students LOVED them and looked forward to the day it was their turn to sit on them. The love of the balls actually sparked the idea to get a classroom set.
Where did you get the funding?
My third grade students wrote letters to the Parent Association stating reasons the balls were a benefit to their education and asked for funding from the PA as well. They put together a presentation to present at a PA meeting and the rest was history. How could they say no to such logical arguments laid out by 8 and 9 year olds?
What was the reaction from students?
Saying the students love the balls is an understatement. They enjoy that they don’t have to “sit still” anymore. They are very careful to follow the expectations so they can continue to enjoy the privilege.
What was the reaction from parents?
Parents I have talked to appreciated the process we went through to get the balls. They are still relatively new, so I am eager to see what they have to say.
What was the reaction from other teachers/administrators?
Many teachers at my school and other teacher friends think I am crazy. They “couldn’t deal with that.” I agree, I am a little crazy. But, I also am willing to try new things. I want what is best for my students and chairs were not the best option. Why not try something else? I will be the first to admit the first week was rough, but things have settled into a routine.
My principal was very supportive. She encouraged me to give it a try and helped me get connected with the Parent Association. She saw them for the first time this week and was impressed with how calm the students looked.
What do you think are the benefits?
MOVEMENT. My students can now move while sitting still. It was hard to get used to at first…all the movement, but it is getting easier. They are able to get their wiggles out during a lesson. Trips to the water fountain and bathroom have decreased. They no longer need to make up an excuse to get out of their seat. I also like how much quieter they are than chairs constantly clattering. Also, we can do brain breaks with them. I can stop in between lessons and we can do sit-ups on our balls. The benefits are endless!
What have been the struggles or downsides?
Just like anything new in the classroom it takes time for the novelty to wear off. They are balls—in the classroom. Heck, I want to see how high I can bounce on them! High and consistent expectations have been key. They set the expectations as a class and we go over them at the beginning of every day and after lunch/recess. Safety is the main priority. There are also a couple students who are more distracted sitting on the balls.
How do they work with students- do all students use them all day? Do they also have regular chairs? Do they get to decide which seat to use at any given time?
As mentioned above, some students are distracted by sitting on a ball. They made the choice on their own to use a chair for most of the day. We have enough for every student in the classroom to sit on a traditional chair, if needed. The beauty is that the students decide when to switch the ball out for a chair or vice-versa. We brainstormed reasons we would want to use one over the other and they are becoming good at knowing what they need and when. We use “practice cards” from Whole Brain Teaching. If a student is given 3 practice cards in one day they do not get the option to use the ball the remainder of the day. Usually one practice card is enough of a reminder to sit safely. Choice is a large part of our classroom culture.
What else can you tell us that might inform other teachers about these seats?
I highly suggest paying an extra couple dollars for a weighted ball. Technically, I could have bought the cheaper ones and funneled 2 pounds of sand in each ball myself. But, who has time for that?! The weight keeps the balls from rolling around the classroom.
There are a few different sizes to choose from. I got the 75cm ones, which are a bit too large, but I can let some of the air out. Our previous 2 balls were 55 cm and just a little too small for the majority of our third grade students. I would recommend the 65 cm ones.
Any last words of advice?
I would like to tell teachers to not be afraid to give it a try. If it is a disaster, I am sure the P.E. teacher could find a use for them in class. Oh, and it will smell like rubber in your classroom for a few days. My students called it the “new ball smell.” Enjoy!
What do you think? Would you try these seats? We would love to hear your opinion. Please leave a comment below!
Happy bouncing,
Rahni Kay Haverland is a third grade teacher at St. Anthony School in Dubuque, Iowa. In addition to teaching, she is married and has a young daughter.